Comments on: Redacted LIMITED DVDRip XviD-SAPHiRE

By: BarneyGumble

BarneyGumble — Wed, 13 Feb 2008 05:03:31 +0000

english subs for this release
http://subs.motechnet.com/title/tt0937237/

By: Isam

Isam — Tue, 12 Feb 2008 14:48:06 +0000

At last someone that is not brain washed, describes the pain and agony that every iraqi lives due to American invasion, lots of voices say that this is only a very small percentage of soldiers actions, but let us assume that she was a French girl that was rapped under Nazi invasion, would not this movie be a master piece in this case, every one that hate this movie, hate it because the power unbiased message that it deliver, Brain washed Americans wake up, you screwed big time in Iraq, and you deserve to be called the new barbarians

By: Byzantine

Byzantine — Sun, 10 Feb 2008 12:38:20 +0000

errmm… english subs anyone?

By: sloopadoop

sloopadoop — Sat, 09 Feb 2008 17:36:07 +0000

I’m an open minded person who feels that that Iraq war was a huge mistake perpetratedon the basis of misrepresentation. I watched this movie from start to finish. While I feel it is fair game to tell this story as it is based on real events, I found it to be extremely poorly executed. Brian Depalma, who i normally find to be an excellent director, did a lackluster job of making the characters and the story believable. I think this story could have been told in a much more effective and thought provoking manner.

By: stephen

stephen — Sat, 09 Feb 2008 03:58:28 +0000

would appreciate a link to the srt subtitles for this.

thanks

By: Dorje

Dorje — Fri, 08 Feb 2008 20:36:16 +0000

I propose the adoption of the Ari Gold plan for world peace as presented in season 1 of Entourage (Man I love that show).
“Let’s Hug It Out B1tch”

By: The Warner

The Warner — Fri, 08 Feb 2008 17:43:17 +0000

not.all.US.are.gullible !!BRAVO!!

Those were very thoughtful and mature words. I’d just want to remark that my comment (No 3) was sarcastic, meant to put a finger into the eye of a moron. So if anybody got hooked- don’t blame me

By: not.all.US.are.gullible

not.all.US.are.gullible — Fri, 08 Feb 2008 17:25:58 +0000

Please, not all Americans are so gullible to believe everything we are forcefed to believe… many here know we are a mislead people with some very bad and nasty management… but we are owned by the moneychangers (your country may be as well, sorry.).

They run almost all our communications, TV, radio, newspapers, and our phone bills will one day come straight from the NSA.
Our elections are just for distraction and entertainment, the schools don’t teach real awareness to balance the fake history, our water is poisoned with fluoride (good for teeth, bad for brains), , … etc., etc., etc…

This is nothing new… Russia was on lock-down, North Korea and China… still.

Please understand that most of the Yanks that you meet don’t even know that the late great America is gone and not coming back.

There are many, many, many, wonderful people here… please don’t confuse us for our puppetmasters…. We love all people… and when you hear patriotic comments from us, remember, we are only talking about us, the regular citizens… not the so-called government… and definitely not their ‘foreign policies.

So please, the next time you hear an american saying something really naive or even moronic… just remember, there probably a few idiots not to far from your doorstep as well… thanks for reading.

A Humble Yank.

By: ceystath

ceystath — Fri, 08 Feb 2008 16:44:51 +0000

Hi everyone… Just wanted to mention something. Oil prices went up after 9/11. Went further up after Afghanistan. Skyrocketed after Iraq. To send troops to protect “your interests” is one thing. To topple a dictator is another. Unfortunately both went awry. Instead of protecting them they kicked a hornets nest and made way for the killer bees. According to independent and government studies there were no Al Qaida in Iraq before the war. Now there are everywhere. Soldiers are dying every day and talking about genocide, just look at the numbers. Saddam was a dictator hands down, but what is happening today is 500 deaths per day. Estimated death tolls are 655000 deaths among civilians… not counting armed personnel. Look at this link, just one of many. http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/10/10/AR2006101001442.html
As far the oil is concerned. I suppose that the analysts at the beginning of the war could not even imagine how unstable the entire region, not just Iraq, would be made because of the war. People are getting scared and the prices go up.

P.S: Not to mention who armed and supported Saddam and Bin Ladden initially.

By: Bixy

Bixy — Fri, 08 Feb 2008 14:34:00 +0000

Are there any non-English speaking parts in this film (ie sections that I’ll need the subs for) ?

Ta.

By: Johan

Johan — Fri, 08 Feb 2008 11:56:30 +0000

This movie needed to be made, although done poorly. Truly meant to demonize a serious event to the point of embarrassment. The world’s populous understands that something terrible occurred and repair and amends need made. But this film is nothing but fuel on a fire, just like Salazar’s filming in the movie. To stand witness but do nothing. I saw but one soldier die in this film, when there is a more realistic death count on all sides. Please, produce movies that don’t patronize or make light of life changing event.

By: rising

rising — Fri, 08 Feb 2008 09:47:26 +0000

american soldier is same with other soldier rest of the world there are human sometime make mistake in their life too..
if anyone want to blamed, blamed it to bush admin and mossad too…

By: wq

wq — Fri, 08 Feb 2008 05:30:24 +0000

Defunkt,

I was talking about this:

“i have no respect for those that complain about how horrible life is, i came from little and made something of it…”

That is complete ignorance. There are so many scenarios worst than yours, complaints or no complaints. You’re lucky.

By: Ihopeyouguysaretrolls

Ihopeyouguysaretrolls — Fri, 08 Feb 2008 04:45:06 +0000

rofl so what you guys are saying is we should all bury our heads in the sand. Making movies about true events is wrong because it could hurt the troops. Also we shouldn’t report these incidents hey? Lets keep it secret and refuse to talk about it just to make sure that no patriotic american soldiers get hurt. Great arguement. Censorship and the destruction of freedom of speech are the only way to save our great ‘free’ nation.

By: youareaveryangrycountry

youareaveryangrycountry — Fri, 08 Feb 2008 04:38:54 +0000

From IMDB:
US Voters: 4.3
Non-US Voters: 7.2

58% of US voters voted 1 which just goes to show that they are a bunch of infuriated idiots who don’t agree with the message. Even if you don’t like the movie it is a much better film than any of the truly terrible films in the IMDB bottom 100 that actually deserve 1.